Highgarden

Call to Schedule a Showing

(317) 414-4602

(317) 414-4602

5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234

$1,499,900

Charming front exterior of a two-story home with black and white paint and mature trees at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Baths

    5

  • Sq. Feet

    4532

  • Year Built

    1950

  • Days on Market

    5

  • $/SqFt

    $331

135 Photos

  • Charming front exterior of a two-story home with black and white paint and mature trees at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • A modern two-story home with a minimalist front yard and a striking black and white exterior at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Stunning backyard featuring a pool, patio, and staircase to an upper deck with wood railings at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Modern front entrance with black door and sidelights, black house numbers, and decorative planters at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Welcoming foyer with modern light-colored flooring, staircase, and black front door at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Open-concept living space with hardwood floors, modern furniture, and lots of natural light at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright, white kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, an island, and decorative backsplash at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • White kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, range hood, and backsplash, plus dark wood ceiling beams at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright kitchen with stainless steel appliances, white countertops, and a large center island at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Kitchen with stainless steel appliances, white cabinets, and a farmhouse sink overlooking the deck at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright living room featuring a modern fireplace with custom black paneling and black ceiling beams at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Open concept living area with modern lighting, a fireplace, and seamless access to a sunroom at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Inviting living room with sleek design features, hardwood floors, and modern furniture at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Spacious living room featuring an open layout with hardwood floors and modern interior design elements at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright sunroom with skylights and large windows bringing the outdoors in at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Sunroom featuring plenty of natural light, neutral tones, and wood floors at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Modern dining room featuring stylish decor, a wood dining table, and an area rug at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Dining room featuring modern finishes, hardwood floors, and a large window showcasing natural light at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bonus room with modern finishes, built-in cabinets, and large windows at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Spacious bonus room with built-in shelves and cabinetry offering plenty of space at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright bedroom features french doors, neutral walls, and plush carpeting at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
More Photos \/
  • Bright bedroom features french doors, neutral walls, and plush carpeting at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • View from the black wood balcony showing the wooded landscape beyond at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Beautiful bathroom with wood vanity, backlit mirror, and tiled shower with tub at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Tiled shower features a freestanding tub and a glass enclosure at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Tiled shower with built-in niche features a freestanding tub at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Tiled shower features rainfall shower head and a freestanding tub at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Tiled shower features a freestanding tub and a built-in niche at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright walk-in closet with white cabinets, shelving, and center island at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright walk-in closet with white cabinets, shelving, and center island at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright bedroom featuring light wood floors, neutral walls, and natural light from the double window at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Modern bathroom features marble tile, glass shower, and a bright window offering a natural light source at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Close up of marble tile shower with modern gold fixtures and built-in tile shelf at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright bedroom featuring light wood floors, neutral walls, and natural light from the double window at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Spacious bedroom boasts plush gray carpeting and two windows offering ample natural light at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright basement featuring light wood floors, neutral walls, with a view of the stairs at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Modern bathroom with vanity, toilet, and tub-shower combo featuring designer tile and gold fixtures at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright bedroom featuring light wood floors, neutral walls, and natural light from the double window at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Modern bathroom with vanity, toilet, and tub-shower combo featuring designer tile and gold fixtures at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Elegant bar area featuring modern cabinetry, a wine fridge, and stylish views into the kitchen at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Beautifully finished living room with a coffered ceiling, and stylish decor throughout at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Striking two-story home showcasing a decorative iron staircase leading to an upper level balcony at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Expansive wooden deck featuring a white brick home with lots of natural light at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Inviting living room featuring a modern bar, blue couches, and a stylish coffee table at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Cozy living room featuring a unique ceiling, sliding doors, and entertainment space at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Spacious basement features interlocking floor tiles, with great lighting and ample space at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Basement area with interlocking floor tiles features a jacuzzi room, and large closet at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Wet bar with a luxurious marble countertop, stainless steel mini fridge and bright windows at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Spacious finished basement with recessed lighting and access to an outdoor space at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Sunroom-enclosed spa features brick accent wall, wood panels and tons of natural light at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Charming exterior of home featuring two-car garage, black trim, concrete driveway and lush landscaping at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright living room boasting vaulted ceilings, modern ceiling fan, neutral furniture and sun-filled windows at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Cozy loft featuring black railing, hardwood floors, neutral paint and bright natural light at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Open-concept living room featuring wood floors, dining area, vaulted ceilings, and neutral furniture at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright, modern kitchen with white cabinets, stainless steel appliances, and a convenient stacked washer/dryer at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Stylish kitchen features stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and white cabinets at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Lush view of home's exterior, showcasing the architecture and scenic surroundings at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Scenic view of the property with a charming wooden bridge amidst a lush, green landscape at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Home featuring a basketball court and stunning architecture, nestled among mature trees at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Home exterior featuring playground equipment, perfect for outdoor activities and Gathering fun at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Well-lit kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, white cabinets, and light wood-look flooring at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Exterior of home with black and white color scheme, two-car garage and lean-to structure at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Open concept living room with vaulted ceilings, exposed beams, and modern furnishings at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Interior view of a wooden barn featuring a sliding door and natural lighting at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Loft area with black beams, light wood floors, and an open view of the living space below at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Spacious garage interior featuring wood paneling, concrete floors and two car garage doors at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright kitchen with white cabinets, stone countertops, and a large window with exterior views at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • A high angle view showcasing a lush green forest from a wooden structure at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Exterior view of a white home surrounded by lush greenery and a rustic wooden fence at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • View of house on grassy hill in woods at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright sunroom with large windows, wood-look floors, and a comfortable seating area with a view of the outdoors at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Exterior black metal staircase with a landing surrounded by lush greenery and a view of the backyard at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Stylish mud room featuring a decorative front door, dark wood paneling, coat hooks, and integrated bench seating at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Mud room featuring a decorative front door, white walls, dark wood paneling, and integrated bench seating at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Garage exterior with modern black garage door and white brick, surrounded by a landscaped yard and greenery at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Garage exterior with modern black garage door and white brick, address detail, and surrounding landscaped yard at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Unfinished basement with exposed wood ceiling, unfinished walls, and a painted concrete floor at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Clean garage interior featuring a clear garage door and a basketball hoop, offering a versatile space at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Convenient laundry area with a modern stacked washer and dryer unit in a bright and clean space at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Modern stacked washer and dryer unit with white cabinets in a bright and clean laundry area at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright bathroom featuring a modern bathtub with stylish marble tile surround and gold fixtures at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Finished basement area with a cozy seating arrangement and sliding doors to the exterior at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Stylish finished basement with recessed lights, exposed beams and contemporary furniture at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Basement kitchenette includes a wine fridge, white cabinets and modern faucet and sink at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bathroom featuring modern gray vanity, gray tile floors, and gold fixtures throughout at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Updated bathroom features stylish gray vanity and gold fixtures, plus tiled shower with glass door at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Modern bathroom with glass enclosed shower, rain-style shower head, and gold fixtures at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Recently updated bathroom with glass shower door, rain-style shower head and modern accents at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Modern bathroom features a steam shower, sauna, gray vanity and gold fixtures at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Interior view of sauna room complete with wooden benches and a traditional heater at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Relaxing hot tub in sunroom with wood ceiling and bright, natural light at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bathroom with wooden vanity, double sinks, large mirror, and modern fixtures at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bathroom featuring double vanity, tub, shower with black-framed glass enclosure at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Beautiful bathroom featuring a modern shower and a luxurious freestanding tub at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Contemporary bathroom featuring a soaking tub behind a framed glass shower enclosure at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bathroom featuring an open shower, luxury blue tiling, and gold fixtures at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bathroom features gorgeous blue tilework, a soaking tub, and an arched shelf at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Cozy bedroom with a large window, closet, and plush carpet flooring at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright bathroom features a soaking tub and shower with marble tile surround at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright kitchen with stainless steel appliances, white cabinets, and an island at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bright, open kitchen featuring a center island, stainless steel appliances, and hardwood floors at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • An expansive kitchen with an island, stainless steel appliances and white cabinets at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Kitchen island with quartz countertop, stainless steel refrigerator, and decorative flower arrangement at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • White cabinets and stainless steel fridge alongside a light wood colored desk at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • A kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, white cabinets, and a range hood at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bathroom with a vanity, mirror, and frosted window at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Empty bedroom with hardwood floors, window and neutral walls at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bedroom with a closet and en-suite bathroom at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Modern bathroom with glass shower, black tile accent wall, and vanity at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bathroom with white vanity, modern toilet and window at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Modern bathroom featuring a glass shower, marble walls, and white penny tile floor at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Spacious walk-in closet with custom shelving, drawers, and central island with quartz countertop at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Bedroom featuring plush gray carpet, view into ensuite bathroom, and view of hallway at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Two-story home with white brick, black trim, modern address numbers, and circular driveway at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Front entrance featuring a black door, white brick, modern address numbers, and black trim at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Dining room features wood table, six chairs, a patterned rug, and three windows with view at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Dining room features wood table, six chairs, a patterned rug, and three windows with view at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Living room featuring light wood floor, large window with wood trim, and built-in bookcase at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Living room with modern fireplace, black accent wall, and light colored wood floors at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Open concept kitchen featuring white cabinets, stainless steel appliances, and light wood flooring at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Scenic aerial view of a charming home nestled among lush trees at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Expansive aerial view of a home surrounded by mature trees, and a shimmering lake in the background at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Wide aerial shot showcases a home with a pool amidst a lush, green landscape and neighborhood in the distance at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Inviting backyard features a pristine pool and ample seating area at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Aerial view of home with pool, deck, and wooded surroundings at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Charming home with a driveway winding through mature trees at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Inviting home with meticulous landscaping and a private setting at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Beautiful home with a manicured lawn and a peaceful, wooded backdrop at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Picturesque home nestled among mature trees, offering privacy and charm at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Striking home exterior with modern details, surrounded by natural beauty at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Charming two-story home featuring a modern exterior with a black roof, black trim and a wooded lot at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • View of a two-story home with an attached garage, black roof, black trim, and landscaped yard at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Beautiful view of a two-story home with a black roof, black trim, and surrounded by woods at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Beautiful two-story home featuring a modern exterior, black roof, black trim, and front yard at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
  • Scenic view of a two-story home featuring a modern exterior, black roof, black trim, and wooded lot at 5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46234
Less Photos /\

Tour This Home

Sun
4 May
Mon
5 May
Tue
6 May
Wed
7 May
Thu
8 May
Fri
9 May
Sat
10 May

Home Description

Experience unparalleled luxury and privacy with this exceptional 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath home, meticulously updated with custom finishes throughout. Set on nearly 5 acres of serene land neathis property offers panoramic views of nature, ensuring a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Step inside to discover gorgeous luxury vinyl plank flooring extending throughout most of the home, complemented by upscale custom features like a stunning wooden accent wall in the great room and custom built-ins in the office. The heart of this home is the gourmet kitchen, boasting high-end stainless steel appliances, quartz countertops, a central island, and breakfast bar-perfect for entertaining and culinary adventures. The great room impresses with its vaulted wood beam ceiling and cozy fireplace, creating a warm and inviting space. Start your day in the all-glass sunroom, which offers breathtaking views of the Gunite pool and the lush landscape beyond. The lower level of the home features two additional bedrooms, a full bath, a spacious recreational area, and a few more steps down, a convenient workout room. Ascending to the top level, you'll find the opulent primary suite, complete with a custom walk-in closet featuring a quartz countertop center island and plenty of storage. The European-inspired spa-like bath is adorned with custom marble tile, a double vanity, and a shower with an integrated soaking tub. The suite's private balcony provides a tranquil overlook of the pool and idyllic surroundings. Another bedroom on this level includes an ensuite bath for added comfort and privacy.Outside, the home continues to impress with a freshly painted exterior, new garage doors, and a roof that enhances its design. Additionally, there's a 2-car attached garage and a 2-car detached garage/renovated barn, which includes an apartment with a kitchenette, loft bedroom, entertaining area, and balcony-ideal for guests or additional living space. Eagle Creek Park area

  • Property Type: Single Family
  • Style: TraditonalAmerican
  • Basement: Yes
  • Garage Spaces: 2
  • Acres: 3-5 Acres
  • Lot Description: Wooded
  • Siding: Brick

Available now at $1,499,900

Approximate Room Sizes / Descriptions

Living Room21x16Main
Dining Room15x14Main
Breakfast Room9x14Main
Kitchen12x14Main
Mud Room10x10Main
Laundry10x10Main
Sun Room44x11Main
Great Room21x14Main
Play Room23x21Basement
Utility Room40x13Basement
Bedroom 510x12Upper
Primary Bedroom16x16Upper
Bedroom 212x16Upper
Bedroom 311x13Basement
Bedroom 411x12Basement
  • Interior Description: Entrance Foyer
  • Full Baths: 4
  • Half Baths: 1
  • Num Fireplaces: 1
  • Fireplace Description: Family Room
  • Primary Bedroom Description: Balcony,Closet Walk in
  • Appliances: Dishwasher,Disposal,Dryer,Electric Cooktop,Electric Oven,Gas Water Heater,Microwave,Refrigerator,Washer,Water Heater
  • Eating Area: Formal Dining Room
  • Heating: Forced Air
  • : Jamie.Boer@Compass.com

Neighborhood

The average asking price of a 5 bedroom Indianapolis home in this zip code is $550,767 (63.3% less than this home).

This home is priced at $331/sqft, which is 58.4% less than similar homes in the 46234 zip code.

Map | Street | Birds Eye

Print Map | Driving Directions

School Information

  • School District:MSD Pike Township

Financial

  • Approx Payment:$6,072*
  • Semi Annual Taxes:$2,572

Area Stats

These statistics are updated daily from the Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS® Multiple Listing Service. For further analysis or to obtain statistics not shown below please call Highgarden Real Estate at (317) 414-4602 and speak with one of our real estate consultants.

Listing Courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC. For information or to schedule a viewing of this property (MLS# 22036255), call: 317-414-4602

5190 Potters Pike, Indianapolis IN is a single family home of 4532 sqft and is currently priced at $1,499,900 . This single family home has 5 bedrooms. A comparable home for sale at 810 Kendale Ct in Indianapolis is listed at $279,000. In addition to single family homes, Highgarden also makes it easy to find Homes, Condos, New Homes and Foreclosures in Indianapolis, IN. Timberview At Eagle Creek, Woodacre and Marlin Meadows are nearby neighborhoods. MLS 22036255 has been posted on this site since 5/2/2025 (today).

2025

Message Agent

Send

Schedule a tour

5190 Potters Pike Indianapolis IN 46234

Choose a day and time

You Requested

We'll be in touch shortly to confirm your tour time and other details. Please let us know how to reach you.

Schedule Tour

CLOSE

Your message has been sent!

The agent will be in touch with you in just a minute.